Compare
Pottery Barn vs West Elm return policy
Return windows, free shipping, price match, mail return fees and holiday rules at Pottery Barn and West Elm, side by side, from each store’s own policy.
The short answer
- Both give 30 days for most items, so the exceptions below decide it.
Shop at Pottery Barn Shop at West Elm
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link. It never changes what we report. How we make money.
Pottery Barn vs West Elm side by side
| Pottery Barn | West Elm | |
|---|---|---|
| Return window | 30 days | 30 days |
| Free shipping | Not listed | Not listed |
| Price match | Own prices only | Own prices only |
| Mail return fee | No fee listed | No fee listed |
| Holiday returns | None listed yet | None listed yet |
| No receipt | An original receipt or gift receipt is required for every return and exchange. | Eligible items can be returned within 30 days of receiving the order, for a refund of the merchandise value. An original receipt or gift receipt is required. |
| Good to know | An original receipt or gift receipt is required for every return and exchange. | An original receipt or gift receipt is required. |
| Shop | Shop at Pottery Barn | Shop at West Elm |
Pottery Barn exceptions
- Quick Ship upholstery: 7 days
- Registry purchases: 90 days after your event or after purchase, whichever is later
- Not returnable: monogrammed items, mattresses, gift cards, Made to Order items (custom rugs, furniture, faucets and shower sets), final sale items with prices ending in .97, and items damaged through normal wear and tear
- No original receipt or gift receipt: not returnable
Full details, sources and the date we checked: Pottery Barn return policy.
West Elm exceptions
- Quick Ship upholstery: 7 days
- Not returnable: items without an original or gift receipt, monogrammed or personalized items, Made to Order items (custom rugs and furniture), mattresses, gift cards, Open Box and final sale items (prices ending in .97), items damaged through normal wear and tear
Full details, sources and the date we checked: West Elm return policy.
Quick answers
Which has the better return policy, Pottery Barn or West Elm?
Both give 30 days for most items, so the exceptions below decide it. The right choice depends on what you are buying; check the exceptions for your item.
Can I return a Pottery Barn item to West Elm?
No. Each store only takes back what it sold. Return the item to the store you bought it from.
Both stores’ rules come from their own policy pages, checked October 13, 2026. Sources are on each store page.